Analyzing the Impacts of Solar Energy Production Plans on Rural Settlements: A Case Study of Hamon and Hirmand Counties

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Associate Professor, Faculty of Geography and Environmental Planning, University of Sistan and Baluchistan, Zahedan, Iran

2 Ph.D. student of Geography and Rural Planning, University of Sistan and Baluchistan, Zahedan, Iran

Abstract

Introduction
Recent droughts in the Sistan region have severely impacted traditional livelihoods, particularly agriculture, fisheries, and animal husbandry, in the rural areas of Hamon and Hirmand. In response, solar panel projects have been initiated in these underserved villages to replace lost income, produce energy, and promote sustainability. The establishment of solar power plants aims to achieve multiple objectives: ensuring a healthy energy supply, stabilizing populations, and alleviating economic poverty in Hamon and Hirmand. These efforts have transformed some villages into centers of solar electricity production. This research seeks to evaluate the impact of solar panel installations on the stability of rural settlements in Hamon and Hirmand, addressing two primary questions: 1) What is the economic efficiency of the installed solar panels for residents? 2) How do social acceptance and satisfaction levels regarding the solar panels compare among the local population?
 
Methodology
This study employs a descriptive-analytical methodology based on survey research. To address the research questions, both documentary and field methods were utilized. The statistical population consists of 30 villages in Hamon and Hirmand. The analysis unit includes heads of households with solar panels, comprising 180 households from 15 villages in Hamon and 162 households from 15 villages in Hirmand. In total, 342 heads of households were selected as the sample population, surveyed through questionnaires and field observations. Data analysis involved cost-benefit analysis and one-sample T-tests conducted in SPSS.
 
Findings
To answer the first research question, cost-benefit analysis results indicated that the project has generated reasonable income in its initial years, making solar panel installation financially viable. With a projected 20% increase in electricity purchase prices, profits for rural households are expected to rise, as the initial investment in solar panels incurs no ongoing costs. Given the anticipated energy shortages in 2024 and the government's commitment to renewable energy, the outlook for new energy projects appears promising. Guaranteed purchase agreements and price increases could further enhance the economic benefits of these initiatives. Additionally, survey results reflected strong economic efficiency for solar energy projects, with household satisfaction regarding solar panel income ranking highest, followed by optimism about future profitability and overall satisfaction. Regarding the second research question, findings revealed favorable social impacts from solar panel projects, with increasing acceptance trends. The highest average satisfaction was linked to community cooperation in promoting cultural acceptance of solar energy, followed by public acceptance of the solar panel initiative and a sense of responsibility for maintenance. Environmentally, the solar projects have successfully reduced reliance on fossil fuels, conserved water resources, and optimized the use of renewable energy. Activists in Hamon and Hirmand reported a strong belief in renewable technologies, awareness of environmental importance, and recognition of solar energy advantages over fossil fuels.
 
Discussion and Conclusion
The villagers' response to solar panel projects has been overwhelmingly positive, driven by factors such as increased income, improved quality of life, and enhanced energy independence. These projects foster innovation, community engagement, and environmental stewardship. However, challenges remain, particularly from harsh weather conditions in the Sistan region, which can damage solar panels and reduce energy absorption due to dust accumulation. In summary, the implementation of solar energy projects has yielded several positive outcomes, including:

Increased Household Income: Many villagers can now generate their own energy and sell excess electricity, enhancing their financial stability.
Energy Accessibility: Solar panel installations have provided reliable energy sources in rural areas, particularly in Hirmand, where access to sustainable electricity is limited.
Reduced Energy Costs: Households have significantly lowered their electricity expenses through solar energy production.
Environmental Protection: Utilizing renewable energy helps decrease dependence on fossil fuels and mitigates environmental degradation.
Innovation and Entrepreneurship: The renewable energy infrastructure supports the development of new businesses in clean energy and related sectors.
Education and Awareness: Accompanying educational programs have increased villagers' understanding of renewable energy and its optimal use.
Social and Economic Stability: Improved incomes and living conditions have strengthened the social and economic fabric of rural communities, fostered a stable environment and encouraged population retention.

Keywords

Main Subjects


Adabi Mamqani, Mohammad, Ruknuddin Iftikhari, Abdul Reza, Portahari, Mohammadi, Sadeghi Saqdel, Hossein (2019). Honoring the level of acceptance of solar energy technology in rural areas (case study: rural areas of Kalibar and Khodaafrin, East Azerbaijan Province), Human Geography Research, Volume 52, Number 1, pp. 283-301. (in Persian)
Amini, Abbas, Moradi, Nusrat, and Sadeghian, Farzaneh (2018), an analysis on the effect of natural factors on the evacuation of rural settlements using GIS and statistical methods in the evacuated villages of Isfahan province), Scientific-Research Quarterly of the Geographical Space of the University Azad Ahar, year 19, number 65, pp. 269-298. (in Persian)
Amole, Abraham O, Oladipo, Stephen  Olakunle E, Olabode, Makinde, Kehinde A, Gbadega, Peter. (2023). Analysis of grid/solar photovoltaic power generation for improved village energy supply: A case of Ikose in Oyo State Nigeria, Renewable Energy Focus, Volume 44, 186-211. doi.org/10.1016/j.ref.2023.01.002
Anabestani, Ali Akbar, Mahmoudi, Hamida (2018). Analysis of the effect of Imam Khomeini Relief Committee loans on the sustainable employment of villagers in the case of Mashhad city, Space Economy and Rural Development Quarterly, 8, (29), 129-150. (in Persian)
Asakre, Abbas, Ghadirianfar, Mohsen, Sheikh Davodi, Mohammad Javad (2015). Feasibility of generating electricity from rooftop solar panels in rural areas of Khuzestan province, Geography and Development, No. 43, pp. 113-132. (in Persian)
Asghari Lafamjani, Sadegh, Shahraki, Isa, Naderian Far, Mehdi. (2015). Obstacles to the economic and social empowerment of the studied rural households: the beneficiaries covered by the aid committee in Sistan, Space Economy and Rural Development Quarterly, Year 5, Number 1, Series 1, 103-124. (in Persian)
Azizpour, Farhad, Khodakarmi, Zahra (2015). Socio-economic effects of agricultural micro-credits in rural areas: a case study: Kersaf district, Space Economy and Rural Development Quarterly, fourth year, number 3, serial 13, 57-69. (in Persian)
Brunet, Carole, Savadogo, Oumarou, Baptiste, Pierre, Michel, A (2022). Does solar energy reduce poverty or increase energy security? A comparative analysis of sustainability impacts of on-grid power plants in Burkina Faso, Madagascar, Morocco, Rwanda, Senegal and South Africa, Energy Research & Social Science, 87, 102212. doi.org/10.1016/j.erss.2021.102212
Dari Sadeh, Solmaz (2019), empowerment with an approach to sustainable rural development, Spatial Research Journal, Tehran, 5th year, number 1, pp. 1-20. (in Persian)
Ghanbari, Youssef, Nouri, Razieh (2016). Evaluating the impact of micro-credits of the aid committee on the survival of the population in the rural areas of Khomein city, Economic Research Quarterly, 17th year, number 65, pp. 177-198. (in Persian)
Hamoon County Governorship. (2023). (in Persian)
Jalilian, Nasreen, Popzan, Abolhamid, (2018). Obstacles and limitations to the success of self-sufficiency and entrepreneurship projects of the Imam Khomeini Relief Committee (RA): case study: women heads of households in Harsam district, Islamabad Gharb city, Space Economy and Rural Development Quarterly, 8th year, number 1 of 27, pp. 2131-2322 . (in Persian)
Khalid, Rihab, Landini, Stefano, Valasai, Gordhan Das, Khalid, Faryal, Sandwell, Philip. (2023). Towards equitable and inclusive energy systems for remote off-grid communities: A socio-technical assessment of solar power for village Helario in Tharparkar, Pakistan, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Transition, 4, 100067. doi.org/10.1016/j.rset.2023.100067
Kimiaei Khalilabad, Amir Javad. (1999). Optimal Allocation of Agricultural Water of Sistan River, Master Thesis, Faculty of Agriculture, Zabul University. (in Persian)
Mehboubi, Mohammadreza, Bagheri, Mahdia, Abdullahzadeh, Gholamhossein. (2018). Pathology of small and household business plan of relief committee in Golestan province, Social Work Quarterly, 8 (2), 24-32. (in Persian)
Moghari, Alireza, Taosi, Taghi (2012). Feasibility assessment and zoning of places prone to install solar panels based on climate parameters in Sistan and Baluchistan Province, Journal of Energy Planning and Policy Research, Year 1, Number 1, pp. 99-114. (in Persian)
Mohadi, Reza, Samian, Masoud. (2017). Investigating the factors affecting the migration of villagers in Sardasht city, Scientific-Research Quarterly of Human Settlements Planning Studies, Volume 13, Number 1, 177-163. (in Persian)
Mohammadi Yeganeh, Behrouz, Sanai Moghadam, Soroush. (2016). Analysis of the effects of city-rural relations in rural-urban migrations, case study: Pashteh Zilai village, Dehdasht city, Regional Planning Quarterly, year 7, serial number 27, 103-116.
Mungongo, C G (2003). Social transformation and Political empowerment in the Age of Globalization. Nordic Journal of African Studies, 12(2), P. 119-133. doi.org/10.53228/njas.v12i2.322
Nikkhah Dehnavi, Arman, Nurkjoy, Haniyeh and Zamardian, Zahrasadat. (1402). Feasibility of removing deprivation by energy production with photovoltaic panels in deprived areas of Iran, Scientific Quarterly of Renewable and New Energy, Volume 10, Number 1, 142-152. (in Persian)
Pour, Samira, Asode Yadaki, Habib Elah. (1401). The role of prudent lifestyle in empowering women heads of households of Imam Khomeini (RA) relief committee beneficiaries in Khorasan Razavi province, Khorasan cultural-social studies quarterly, 16th year, 3rd issue, pp. 7-36. (in Persian)
Shafii Thabit, Nasser, Zare Khalili, Hassan, Tawakli, Soha (2016). Measuring the potentials of solar energy in the development of rural settlements in Maroodasht city, Quarterly Journal of Space Economy and Rural Development, 6th year, number 3, serial 21, pp. 101-120. (in Persian)
Shamsi, Hezhir,, Heshmatian, Mohmatar, Shamsi, Setareh, Shamsi, Soheila. (2012). Economic benefits of using renewable energies, a solution for sustainable development of solar energy, Second Conference on Environmental Planning and Management, University of Tehran. https://civilica.com/doc/147939/(in Persian)
Statistical Center of Iran. (2023). (in Persian)
Ulsrud, Kirsten, Rohracher, Harald, Winther, Tanja, Muchunku, Charles, Palit, Debajit. (2018). Pathways to electricity for all: What makes village-scale solar power successful, Energy Research & Social Science, 44, 32-40. doi.org/10.1016/j.erss.2018.04.027
Xuan Ao, Hoa, Eftekhari, Mahdi, Aungkulanon, Pasura, Almutairi, Khalid, Mostafaeipour, Ali. (2022). Impact of economic and government investment in residential solar power plant on energy system sustainability, Sustainable Energy Technologies and Assessments, 52, , 102050. doi.org/10.1016/j.seta.2022.102050
Zandi, Rahman, Safaei, Mohammad Javad, Khosrovian, Maryam (2018). The title of the survey potential of using solar energy in the rural areas of Sabzevar, Geography and Development, No. 57, 17th year, pp. 94-69. (in Persian)
Ziari, Keramatollah (2023), Schools, theories and models of regional planning and programming, fourth edition, Tehran, Tehran University Press. (in Persian)